Are EVs Cheaper Than Gas Cars? Build Your Own 5-Year Comparison
There is no universal winner. This guide shows how to compare an EV and a gas car with the same mileage, local energy prices, actual insurance quotes, maintenance schedules, incentives and realistic resale scenarios.
An EV can cost less to operate while still costing more to own. The answer depends on purchase price, charging access, annual mileage, energy prices, insurance, maintenance, financing, taxes, incentives and resale value. A useful comparison keeps those assumptions visible instead of relying on a national average that may not match either vehicle.
Step 1: Compare Like With Like
Choose vehicles that meet the same needs: passenger space, cargo capacity, performance and expected ownership period. Use the negotiated drive-away price for each vehicle. Subtract only incentives for which you are actually eligible, and account for timing if a credit is received later rather than at purchase.
Step 2: Calculate Gas Cost
For US units, annual gallons equal annual miles divided by real-world MPG. Multiply gallons by your expected price per gallon. For metric units, multiply annual kilometers by L/100 km, divide by 100 and multiply by price per liter. Use a conservative fuel-economy figure that reflects weather, traffic and highway mix.
Step 3: Calculate Charging Cost
Annual vehicle energy equals annual distance multiplied by energy consumption. Add charging losses, then apply a blended electricity price based on the share charged at home, work and public fast chargers. Include unavoidable session or parking fees separately. A driver relying on public fast charging may see a very different result from a driver with off-peak home charging.
Step 4: Use Actual Insurance Quotes
Request quotes for both exact vehicles using identical drivers, address, mileage, limits and deductibles. Vehicle technology alone does not determine the premium; repair costs, theft experience, local claims, driver profile and insurer pricing all matter. Enter the full annual quote rather than a generic EV surcharge.
Step 5: Build a Maintenance Schedule
Use each manufacturer's maintenance schedule and price the items likely to occur during your ownership period. EVs remove oil changes and some engine-related service, but both vehicle types need tires, alignment, cabin filters, wipers and checks. Tire wear, out-of-warranty repairs and local labor rates can outweigh a simplistic annual allowance.
Step 6: Model Depreciation as a Range
Depreciation is often the largest ownership cost and the hardest to forecast. Collect current used-market values for comparable models and run at least three end-value scenarios: conservative, middle and optimistic. Include expected mileage and condition. Avoid assuming every EV or every gas car follows the same percentage.
Step 7: Add Financing and Home-Charging Costs
Compare loan offers using the same term and down payment, then include total interest and fees. For an EV, add any electrical work or charging equipment you would not otherwise buy. If that equipment may serve a future vehicle, you can also run a scenario that spreads the cost across a longer period.
An Illustrative Break-Even Example
Suppose an EV costs $5,000 more after applicable incentives and saves $900 per year in energy and maintenance after accounting for a $150 difference in insurance. The simple operating-cost payback is $5,000 ÷ $900, or about 5.6 years. That is not a complete ownership result: a different resale value, loan rate or charger-installation cost can move the answer materially.
Decision Checklist
- Use the same annual distance and ownership years for both vehicles.
- Enter local prices and actual quotes rather than article averages.
- Include purchase taxes, incentives and financing consistently.
- Test home-only, blended and public-heavy charging scenarios when relevant.
- Run more than one resale-value assumption.
- Treat a result within a few percent as effectively uncertain, not a guaranteed winner.
The calculator is best used as a scenario tool. Save the inputs behind the result and update them when a quote or local price changes.
Sources & editorial note
These primary or regulatory resources support the concepts and next steps in this guide. The article does not scrape live prices; examples are reviewed against the published formulas.