Why monthly payments are not enough
Lease payments are often lower because they mainly cover depreciation during the term, rent charges, taxes and fees; returning the car usually leaves no equity. Loan payments are higher but reduce principal and build vehicle equity. Compare both over the same period using cash paid plus remaining debt minus resale value.
Buy net cost = cash paid + remaining loan − estimated resale value
Lease cost = signing cash + all payments + acquisition fee + end charges
Keep the comparison apples-to-apples
Shared insurance, energy and parking costs can be omitted from both sides. If a cost truly differs, enter only the difference. Tax treatment and whether signing or acquisition fees are already embedded vary by location and contract, so avoid double-counting.
Frequently asked questions
Why count the lease down payment in full?
It lowers the payment but does not create vehicle equity and generally is not a refundable deposit. Treat it as cash spent and verify contract treatment, especially after early termination or a total loss.
How should I estimate resale value?
Use conservative net proceeds for the expected age, mileage and condition, after selling costs. Test at least three values because depreciation is often the most sensitive assumption.
How do I handle excess mileage?
Multiply expected excess distance by the contract charge per mile or kilometer, add expected wear charges, and enter the total as lease-end charges.
Does this include buying the car at lease end?
No. This scenario assumes return at term end. A buyout adds the contractual residual, option fees, taxes and possibly another loan, so model it separately.
Is one option always better?
No. Mileage limits, early-termination risk, replacement frequency, modifications, warranty coverage and willingness to bear resale risk also matter.